Nearly all publishers and stand-alone journals (91.9%), as well as the majority of conference hosts (71.2%) identified as potentially predatory in nature were associated with a website; therefore, online verification is not a reliable way of determining the legitimacy of a phishing email. Anna Biszaha, MLIS, and Stephanie J. Schulte, MLIS. The Interacademy Partnership. Emails soliciting articles for predatory journals often contain long URLs, resulting in a copious volume of blue hyperlinks in the body of the message. Required fields are marked *. Medicine and NutritionApril 24-25, 2023New York, New York. Unfortunately, predatory journals that use unsavory publication practices have emerged. While existing databases (e.g., Bealls list and The CalTech Library list of questionable conferences) catalogue many fraudulent senders, the list is ever-expanding. IJNH objective is to provide a platform for the researchers, clinical practitioners and readers who are committed to advancing practice and proficient development by exchanging the knowledge that is directly relevant to all spheres of nursing and midwifery practice. The majority of fake publishers were already included on Bealls list (86.7%). Oermann, Marilyn H. PhD, RN, ANEF, FAAN; Nicoll, Leslie H. PhD, MBA, RN, FAAN; Carter-Templeton, Heather PhD, RN-BC, FAAN; Owens, Jacqueline K. PhD, RN, CNE; Wrigley, Jordan MSLS, MA; Ledbetter, Leila S. MLIS, AHIP; Chinn, Peggy L. PhD, RN, FAAN. Ongoing Pandemic Mental Health Concerns Disabilities in Healthcare A Nurse's Impact Racism and Nurses Advancing Technology in Healthcare COVID-19 Pandemic and Nurses Nursing Education Substance Use Disorders and Related Concerns The 200th Birthday of Florence Nightingale More. . This article shares guidance to help nurses effectively appraise information and their sources, distinguish predatory from legitimate journals, and conduct due diligence. Predatory publishing solicitation: a review of a single surgeon's inbox The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the Title proper: Integrative journal of nursing and medicine. At more than 3 The evolution of journals from print-only to electronic formats ushered in the open access (OA) publishing model. integrative journal of nursing and medicine predatory Before Check. The fee is often not transparent, and journal websites may include misleading information about the costs. The authors work at The Ohio State University Health Sciences Library in Columbus. Predatory journals: No definition, no defence. About Journal. Abstract. PLOS SciComm. Decision-making about complementary and alternative medicine by cancer The firs list, Bealls List of Predatory Journals and Publishers, was created by an academic librarian, Jeffery Beall, and is now maintained and updated by an anonymous source.8 Bealls criteria for selection of questionable online journals include high publication fees and limited peer-review and editorial processes. Mary Ann Liebert, Inc. | Home Quality databases have criteria that journals must meet before being accepted. Search for Similar Articles Username or e-mail * Password * . Consider this type of solicitation a red flag. A preference-based model of care: An integrative theoretical model of In the 1970s, the field of medical humanities developed and included ethics, literature, history, integrative medicine, and other topics, most often described from a physician's perspective. However, this is a subscription-based resource, so check with your library to see if you have access. In general, scholarly journals publish articles written by and for scholars in a particular field. A further review of those 10 predatory journals revealed that 9 were originally published by a reputable publisher, and followed sound editorial and publishing practices at the time they were indexed, but were subsequently purchased by one of the large predatory publishers.15. States are an approximately $9 billion market each year, equal to 3 percent of . The name of the journal reflects its focus. For example, in a study of 459 predatory journals, only 10 were indexed in curated bibliographic databases. Characteristics recorded included the site of origin, presence of grammatical errors, contact information provided, relevance of the invitation to the recipients specialty, as well as whether the sender had already been identified as fraudulent by either Bealls list of potential predatory journals and publishers (beallslist.net) or the CalTech Library list of questionable conferences (https://libguides.caltech.edu/c.php?g=512665&p=3503029). Some error has occurred while processing your request. Journal of Integrative Nursing : Table of Contents includes Schools of Medicine, Nursing, and Public Health as well as an affiliated Primate Center. The good news is that, in addition to consulting with a librarian, reliable organizations have created tools to simplify locating information about journals in question. Many reputable and well-known scholarly journals provide the option to legitimately publish openly or are fully open access. As an example, this article is open access: The authors chose to pay the fee to publish it open access so it would be free for readers and this information could be disseminated widely. I hope that I have been able to shed some light on the confusing topic of predatory journals. Jisc. Beall's List - of Potential Predatory Journals and Publishers It is important to note, however, that 58% of emails (n = 119) did not contain any clues that they were sent from predatory journals,5 making it difficul to distinguish emails from legitimate journals from those that are from predatory journals. Predatory journals refer to unethical publishers intentionally subverting many of the established standards of scholarly publishing to quickly churn out articles and collect associated fees. Journals are indexed in various, curated bibliographic databases (such as PubMed/MEDLINE, CINAHL, Scopus, and others). This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of a Persian Medicine-based dietary protocol (PM diet) in patients infected with COVID-19. nursing journals; open access; predatory journals; publishing; research. Integrative health also emphasizes multimodal interventions, which are two or more interventions such as conventional health care approaches (like medication, physical rehabilitation, psychotherapy), and complementary health approaches (like acupuncture, yoga, and probiotics) in various . Legitimate online only, open access journals have a peer-review process and follow publication ethics and standards, similar to subscription-based journals, including indexing in bibliographic databases.7 Open access journals often charge authors a publication fee. ICMJE | Journals stating that they follow the ICMJE Recommendations 1 Senders from these "journals" and/or "conferences" attempt to disguise their intent and platforms. Some fully open access journals dont charge processing fees (platinum or diamond OA) and some do (gold OA). 4,5 performed an interesting report of predatory journals in our speciality in 2019. characteristics of predatory nursing journals such as types of articles published, article processing charge, and peer review process. 4. N - predatory journals. A cross-sectional comparison, Predatory journals: the rise of worthless biomedical science, Consensus statement on the adoption of the COPE guidelines, The downside of the shifting paradigm of scholarly publishing in the biomedical sciences: predatory publishing, ac.secivreshtlaehatrebla@nosrekcin.nacnud, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/, https://libguides.caltech.edu/c.php?g=512665&p=3503029, https://www.spydermail.com/spam-cost-calculator/, World Journal of Surgery and Surgical Research, International Journal of Critical Care and Trauma, Sent from free provider (e.g., gmail.com), Claim to offer editorial services and/or a peer review process, Broad range of documents accepted (e.g., research, review, case report, editorial, clinical image, letter to editor), Publisher/standalone journal online presence, Organization is verifiable online (i.e., listed on PubMed, Disclaimer present at the end of the email, Use of appealing words to make the journal appear international (e.g., global, world, euro), Previous publications by the recipient are cited in the invitation, Invitation is related to surgeons specialty, Email sent from a free provider like gmail.com, Use of appealing words to make the conference appear international (e.g., global, world, euro). Crit Care Nurse 1 August 2019; 39 (4): 911. . Hundreds of 'predatory' journals indexed on leading - Nature Its easy to be confused about these options, especially when all of them can be completely legitimate and high quality. Flattery is common (for example, Your unbound support towards the scientific community with submission of your valuable, Go to the journal website. Choosing best evidence requires watching for these red flags. Many tools exist to help nurses evaluate journal quality. Oermann and colleagues also found that over 96% of articles analyzed in a sample of predatory nursing journals were of poor-to-average quality. Finally, the journal indicated the authors could withdraw the manuscript if they paid a fee to the editorial office. CNDA Annual ConferenceApril 28-30, 2023Santa Rosa . Narrow scope. Integrative health brings conventional and complementary approaches together in a coordinated way. First, it is important to recognize that these emails are automated, similar to robocalls and texts. To catch a predatory publisher. Highlight selected keywords in the article text. For inclusion in MEDLINE, as an example, a Literature Selection Technical Review Committee evaluates the journal scope and coverage, editorial policies that include the peer-review process used by the journal, scientific and methodological rigor of articles, production quality, and overall significance and impact of the journal.18 Searches also can be done in Scopus, which is a large abstract and citation database of journal articles, conference proceedings, and books. Integrative Medicine Reports is a high-quality open access journal providing peer-reviewed research spanning the spectrum of integrative and complementary medicineincluding botanical medicine, Acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Medicine, mind-body therapies, clinical application of integrative health therapies, and other modalities.. Integrative Medicine Reports publishes peer-reviewed . Added 29 April 2021 Updated 29 April 2021 . Google Scholar is an easy way to search for a wide range of scholarly literature, all in one place.17 Although Google Scholar includes journal articles from legitimate publishers and repositories, conference proceedings, theses and dissertations, books, abstracts, reports, and other types of scholarly literature, it may also include articles from predatory journals. Educators can help to disseminate this information and reviewers and editors can help by screening for predatory journals when they review publications. To locate credible, authoritative, timely, and accurate evidence-based information, the use of Google and Google Scholar only is not recommended. 2016;48(6):624-32. doi:10.1111/jnu.12248, Oermann MH, Nicoll LH, Ashton KS, et al. If a journal brags about quick acceptance of articles or indicates a very short turnaround window, consider it a negative indicator that they may skimp on rigor. Bethesda, MD 20894, Web Policies No formal peer-review and/or editing process may exist, which lowers the quality of the publications.2 In a study of 358 randomly selected articles from predatory nursing journals, investigators found that fewer than 4% were considered to be excellent quality.2 Forero et al3 also questioned whether inadequate peer review may lead to published findings that are potentially harmful to patients. However, just because an article is published in a journal doesnt make it automatically worthy of being used in decision-making or policy development. 8600 Rockville Pike Utilization-focused integrative reviews in a nursing service. Given this complexity, how can we define predatory publishing in a practical way to guide nurse authors? Should I include studies from predatory journals in a systematic review? The difference can be as little as a single word or letter. Beware of predatory journals - American Nurse - Practice Matters We encourage you to continue submitting your articles to high-quality journals from credible publishers, such as AACN, whether the articles are in print or online. and D.N.). Jeffrey Beall, a librarian at the University of Colorado, first coined the term predatory in relation to publishing or journals. October 4, 2017. Your message has been successfully sent to your colleague. This is an important distinction to make as the scientific community moves toward a more open science model in response to scientific cultural shifts and funder mandates. [Journal of Gerontological Nursing, 49(5), 5-10.] During this same period of revolutionary changes in health care, nursing curricula did not seek to emphasize content in humanities, perhaps because . Patient plus health-care provider interpretation of doing not resuscitate and do not intubate. A randomized clinical trial was performed from July 2020 to January 2021 in Tehran, Iran. Nurses should not use Google and Google Scholar only for a search because predatory publications can be found via these search engines, and there is no assurance of the accuracy of the information. Surgery. Summary of phishing emails from predatory publishers seeking manuscript submissions, Summary of phishing emails from predatory stand-alone journals seeking manuscript submissions, Characteristics of phishing emails seeking manuscript submissions. 2. Law and Policy. 2 Academia Arena 1553-992X www.sciencepub.net . Annals of Nursing and Practice Affiliated with the International Society for Complementary Medicine Research. PDF HBI list for Predatory Journals - aui.ac.ir This article shares guidance to help nurses effectively appraise information and their sources, distinguish predatory from legitimate journals, and conduct due diligence. Unfortunately, predatory journals that use unsavory publication practices have emerged. 2018;66(1):4-10. doi:10.1016/j.outlook.2017.05.005. They included the names of journals and publishers listed on Bealls list; the names of conference hosts listed on the CalTech Library list; the names of journals, publishers and conference hosts we deemed to be predatory; the word greetings; and the presence of obvious spelling and/or grammar errors. Integrative Medicine Reports | Mary Ann Liebert, Inc., publishers 11. 6. One nursing practice journal was reported to have as many as 77 citations of articles from predatory journals. 2021;47(2):102271. doi:10.1016/j.acalib.2020.102271, Oermann MH, Conklin JL, Nicoll LH, et al. Various open access models exist, and the terminology used to describe them can be confusing for those less familiar with disseminating scholarly work in journals. The widely used academic database Scopus hosts papers from more than 300 potentially 'predatory' journals that have questionable publishing practices, an analysis has found 1. Case No. Whether writing, citing, or reading journal articles, they must develop a keen awareness to avoid falling prey to predatory publishing, understand the key concepts underpinning the problem, know the indicators that can help evaluate whether a resource may be predatory, and use reputable tools to aid in determining a journals legitimacy. Predatory publishers typically oversee a range of journals.11 Their primary goal in publishing these journals is to make money for the publisher. This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) licence, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided that the original publication is properly cited, the use is noncommercial (i.e., research or educational use), and no modifications or adaptations are made. If something of interest is found only in Google or Google Scholar, then it is important to carefully review the article and verify that it is not from a predatory source.